Skip to main content

Wiki Review: The Chinese Social Credit System

For my Wiki review I chose a paper by Bálint Adám, Dominik Kovács, Benedek Matveev, Luca Mizzi and Carlos Rodriguez on The Chinese Social Credit System.

I think the topic chosen is really interesting, hence why I chose this article to review, and important at the same time. As the Chinese government is really invading people's privacy, at least in my opinion, by tracking its citizens and companies. It's important to know about the problem so we could avoid this also happening in the western world.

All in all, I think the most important aspects of the topic got covered, at least what I was hoping to learn from it while reading the article, and it was presented in a good manner so it was interesting to read.

The structure of the article was good, it was organized in a logical way and was divided into subcategories, although they could have been tied a bit better.

The viewpoint or angle of the article was for the most part pretty neutral as it should be. Maybe it was a bit to the opposing side to the Chinese government at some points, but then again it's hard to write neutrally about such a topic where pretty much any sane person could agree that peoples' lives are being directly manipulated by the government.

I think the chosen sources were pretty okay, they even used some book sources which was positively surprising. One thing that definitely should have been implemented is references for the sources. They only had all of the sources listed at the end of the article but didn't really show where they used specific sources. Also, I would have added timestamps when the sources were accessed as we know that they might become unavailable in the future and we can't access the links anymore. But in general, they had plenty of different sources and not only online ones, so I think they did well, just the formatting could have been better.

As for the language and form, it was mostly good. It did have some grammar/structure mistakes in some places, including wrong capitalization (ie at the start of a sentence or the title of a show) and shortened form which in general should be avoided in formal writings.

All in all, I enjoyed the read, and thank you to the authors for choosing an important topic to talk about! :)


----------------------------

Link to their article: https://wiki.itcollege.ee/index.php/The_Chinese_Social_Credit_System#Comparing_both_realities_-_China_and_Usa_monitoring

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Week 9: Examples of bad and good HCI

With technology developing rapidly, we find all sorts of new ways to improve our lives and how we interact with technology. With technological innovation, we might witness the creation of something life-changing and spectacular or something that just no one even asked for. I'll try to bring examples of both worlds. Firstly I'd like to bring a good example of HCI - eye-tracking. I recently watched either a video on YouTube or a documentary on Netflix (can't really member which) that showed how eye-tracking technologies have changed the lives of people suffering from illnesses like locked-in syndrome. Locked-in syndrome is a condition where people have full cognitive ability but they are unable to move or speak due to paralysis of voluntary muscles. So usually they can only move their eyes, and that's about it, although some can't even do that. They are literally locked in their bodies unable to move and communicate with others. But thanks to eye-tracking, people that...
Post a Comment
Read more

Week 1: Three IT products that resulted in a failure

In the innovative world of IT where the competition is more intense than anywhere else, it is bound that most companies and products will inevitably fail. I will talk about some interesting cases where games caused an uproar upon their release as they sadly failed to meet customers' expectations. The first one on my list and additionally the most recent game is Cyberpunk 2077 which was released less than 2 months ago. Cyberpunk is an open-world action role-playing video game that was released on PC, next-generation consoles (Xbox Series X and PlayStation 5), and older consoles like PlayStation 4 and Xbox One. The game was already announced in 2012 and the game gathered major attraction pretty much from the start. The game was in development for over 8 years and the hype for the game grew especially as the developing company was CD Projekt Red, a company that is infamous for their successful Witcher series. I also had really high hopes for the game knowing that the same company who...
Post a Comment
Read more

Week 5: Copyright reform

In today's blog post I will be sharing my opinion on the book The Case for Copyright Reform by Christian Engströmand Rick Falkvinge and on copyright issues in general. The book starts off with a claim that today’s copyright legislation is out of tune with the times and I must agree with that. There is a dire need for a referendum when it comes to copyright laws, as they are threatening our privacy. And to me, a person who isn't really familiar with all of these copyright laws, it seems that these new laws aren't being passed partly because of big corporations who are afraid to lose part of their income. In the second chapter they bring out some key changes that they propose: Moral Rights Unchanged - when it comes to moral rights, I think these don't really need a change. As said, no one should be able to claim that they are the author of someone else's creations. ”Give credit where credit is due” Free Non-Commercial Sharing - I agree with this point a lot, the curr...
Post a Comment
Read more