Skip to main content

Week 5: Copyright reform

In today's blog post I will be sharing my opinion on the book The Case for Copyright Reform by Christian Engströmand Rick Falkvinge and on copyright issues in general.

The book starts off with a claim that today’s copyright legislation is out of tune with the times and I must agree with that. There is a dire need for a referendum when it comes to copyright laws, as they are threatening our privacy. And to me, a person who isn't really familiar with all of these copyright laws, it seems that these new laws aren't being passed partly because of big corporations who are afraid to lose part of their income.

In the second chapter they bring out some key changes that they propose:

Moral Rights Unchanged - when it comes to moral rights, I think these don't really need a change. As said, no one should be able to claim that they are the author of someone else's creations. ”Give credit where credit is due”

Free Non-Commercial Sharing - I agree with this point a lot, the current laws for non-commercial sharing are just ridiculous. I think that new movies and books shouldn't be available for peer-to-peer downloading, of course, but with old movies or books, for example, I think everyone should be able to download them if it's just for their own use. As said in the book, it's cultural expression and we shouldn't restrict it. But then again to know exactly what people are sharing with one another, someone would have to monitor the stuff being sent which would just be a violation of privacy. So really the two options would be to make everything illegal (like it pretty much is now) or make all downloading for your own use legal.

20 Years of Commercial Monopoly - I agree that today's copyright protection law that protects work for the creator's lifetime plus 70 years is quite absurd and isn't reasonable. As for how much exactly should it be shortened, I do not know, but 20 years is definitely fairer than 70...

Registration After 5 Years - again, I would agree with this change, there are a lot of works that are still copyrighted, yet no owner to be seen. So I think this alternative would at least alleviate the current problem. 

Free Sampling - this one I agree with wholeheartedly, as I have seen musicians and other creators struggle with it quite a lot, for example using literally a two-second sample of a song in their video and having it taken down due to copyright claims.

A Ban on DRM -  I agree with this as one of my dear friends has had problems with it, more specifically with the USA's Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) on a streaming platform called Twitch, essentially getting all of your content banned because a fragment of a song was heard in the background and now you will get banned if that might occur again. I think DRM should bennedor at least it shouldn't be so strict.


Although I managed to only read the first few chapters of the book, it really is a good read and I will definitely read it further and based on what I have read so far, I'd also recommend it to others.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Week 9: Examples of bad and good HCI

With technology developing rapidly, we find all sorts of new ways to improve our lives and how we interact with technology. With technological innovation, we might witness the creation of something life-changing and spectacular or something that just no one even asked for. I'll try to bring examples of both worlds. Firstly I'd like to bring a good example of HCI - eye-tracking. I recently watched either a video on YouTube or a documentary on Netflix (can't really member which) that showed how eye-tracking technologies have changed the lives of people suffering from illnesses like locked-in syndrome. Locked-in syndrome is a condition where people have full cognitive ability but they are unable to move or speak due to paralysis of voluntary muscles. So usually they can only move their eyes, and that's about it, although some can't even do that. They are literally locked in their bodies unable to move and communicate with others. But thanks to eye-tracking, people that...
Post a Comment
Read more

Week 15: IT and Ethics

In my last blog post, I will be touching upon an ethical theory and how I see it implemented in IT. For the theory, I chose Social Contract Theory that was first formulated by the English philosopher Thomas Hobbes. According to the theory, society should strive to develop a set of rules that make sense to everyone (making people follow them voluntarily). For instance, driving on the right (or in some places, left) could be a common example - drivers keep to the right not for fearing the police but to avoid confusion and possible crashes. I think this pretty much describes how online communication and hacking work. Although there aren't really any rules strictly in place other than netiquette rules on how you should behave online or how, who, and if to hack someone, most people obey a set of rules that just make sense to everyone without really having them written down. Even though there are some netiquette rules, it's merely a recommendation, not a requirement. So everyone can ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Week 11: Privacy and censorship

This week's topic was censorship, privacy and the Internet and I'd like to talk about examples of both censorship and privacy. The first thing that pops into my head regarding censorship is the famous Chinese app TikTok. Amongst TikTok already having tons of privacy issues and security risks, TikTok has also been caught censoring its content that would be okay in the Western world and Europe but wouldn't be in China. As TikTok is owned by the Chinese company ByteDance, it cooperates with the Chinese government and they have said this openly before, although they don't really specify exactly how. But TikTok users have noticed how some content that is being posted is heavily censored. Examples of this are the BLM and ACAB movements and Hongkong protests. The app has only one main feed that you can't filter yourself, it just feeds you content based on your watch time, likes, and personal data. So when these movements were at their peak people started noticing how all o...
Post a Comment
Read more